Essential Pizza Restaurants to Visit in Pennsylvania

Faccia Luna Pizzeria, State College, PA

There is perhaps no greater arbiter of good pizza than the contemporary college student, and the verdict is in at Faccia Luna Pizzeria. This State College favorite churns authentic Italian flavor out of its wood fired oven, and their non-pizza offerings are just as tempting. Stop in for a phenomenal pie, or on the weekends for seafood specials, and take advantage at one of the longest al fresco seasons around on their heated porch. 

Square Pie, Philadelphia, PA

Square Pie has become one of the best loved pizza joints in the state, serving up a thick crust pizza inspired by Brooklyn or Sicily, depending whom you ask. BYOB, or just your appetite, and tuck into satisfying combos like the decadent Melanzane or a classic mozzarella. 

Fiori’s Pizzaria, Pittsburgh, PA

This Steel City staple offers up pizzas and hoagies substantial enough to satisfy even the hungriest of bellies. Be sure to order a side of cold cheese to add to your pie, a Fiori’s tradition that just works. 

Maroni’s Pizza, Scranton, PA

Maroni’s has been providing the Scranton area with perfect pizza for over 30 years, and doesn’t seem to plan on slowing down anytime soon. This cash only locale breaks the boring chains of same-old pizza, offering familiar yet fantastic pies guaranteed to impress even the most jaded of customers.   

Stromboli Pizza, Allentown, PA

Stromboli’s is a rare breed whose menu is equal parts extensive and excellent. Quality food, good prices, and large portions have made this Allentown location a must-eat in the Lehigh Valley. $5 will get you two slices and a drink, and coupons on their website can ease the blow of ordering for a crowd. 

Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, Pittsburgh, PA

For a bubbly crust and quality toppings, the Pittsburgh place to be is Proper. Visit for a broad selection of easily customizable pizzas, and quality array of creative Italian-style dishes (brisket mac & cheese anyone?), paired with solid beer, wine, and cocktail lists. Check out their website for food truck locations if you can’t make it to the brick and mortar, or hire the 18-foot trailer for your next event, complete with 5,000 pound Italian wood burning brick oven. 

Pizzeria Stella, Philadelphia, PA

Wood-fired pizza made from fresh ingredients, with inventive topping combinations, Pizzeria Stella is pretty tough to beat. Try the broccoli rabe appetizer or pistachio pizza. 

Key Insights at a Glance

• Pizza is always a great option in Pennsylvania, with a variety of options from food trucks to top-rated restaurants.
• Faccia Luna Pizzeria in State College offers authentic Italian flavor from their wood fired oven, along with seafood specials on weekends.
• Square Pie in Philadelphia serves up thick crust pizzas inspired by Brooklyn or Sicily, and is BYOB.
• Fiori's Pizzaria in Pittsburgh offers substantial pizzas and hoagies, with a side of cold cheese as a must-try tradition.
• Maroni's Pizza in Scranton has been providing perfect pizzas for over 30 years, with familiar yet fantastic pies.
• Stromboli Pizza in Allentown offers quality food, good prices, and large portions, making it a must-eat in the Lehigh Valley.
• Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room in Pittsburgh offers customizable pizzas and creative Italian-style dishes, with the option to hire their food truck for events.
• Pizzeria Stella in Philadelphia serves wood-fired pizzas with inventive topping combinations, such as the broccoli rabe appetizer or pistachio pizza.