Local Favorites: The Top Diners in Wisconsin

Monty’s Blue Plate Diner, Madison, WI

Monty’s Blue Plate Diner is a 1950s-style diner. They serve the best comfort food for all ages and palates. Monty’s has consistently been voted the “Best of Madison” in vegetarian and breakfast menus. Drop in sometime for great service and an eccentric atmosphere. 

Delta Diner, Delta, WI

Delta Diner is a cozy, renovated, 1940s-inspired diner in northern Wisconsin. They have coined themselves as the “center of the middle of nowhere.” Delta Diner is a classic American roadside diner selling their famous breakfast and classic burgers. Stop in for a great dining experience.

Bristol 45 Diner, Bristol, WI

If you are looking for a hearty meal check out Bristol 45 Diner. Order up burgers and other American comfort food. Their vintage 1950s setting is a fun family restaurant that offers monthly special events with classic cars, motorcycles, a visit from the Lone Ranger, and John Van Thiel as the “Voice of Elvis.”

Broadway Diner, Baraboo, WI

The Broadway Diner was opened in 2012 by husband and wife duo Jeff and Vonnie. Their full-service restaurant whips up hash in a flash. Broadway Diner is an authentically-restored 1950s space and is among the best in Baraboo.

Gus’s Diner, Sun Prairie and Verona, WI

Gus’s Diner is a family owned and operated diner with two locations in Wisconsin.  From gigantic burgers to their fresh salad bar, the food at Gus’s won’t disappoint. Breakfast lovers unite because breakfast is served all day!

Hubbard Avenue Diner and Bakery, Middleton, WI

Hubbard Avenue Diner is famous for their pie and known for their great food. Order up classics like meatloaf, burgers, mashed potatoes, and other novelty sandwiches. Stop by Thursday through Sunday for awesome deals on daily specials on chicken, fish, and pot roast. 

Club 23, Wisconsin Dells, WI

Club 23 is a family-owned restaurant located just off Highway 23 in Wisconsin Dells. Sit back and relax in their friendly atmosphere and eat some tasty food. Their hearty entrees come with a dinner roll, soup or salad, and a potato choice. Come hungry, but stay for the atmosphere. 

The Diner, Appleton, WI

Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner— The Diner is the best in Appleton. Choose from appetizers, salads, soups, wraps, breakfast dishes, burgers, sandwiches, seafood, pasta, and homestyle dinners. Be sure to take a look at their delicious dessert selection.

Key Insights at a Glance

• Monty’s Blue Plate Diner, Madison - 1950s-inspired diner known for its comfort food and winning vegetarian and breakfast options.
• Delta Diner, Delta - Cozy, retro diner dubbed the "center of the middle of nowhere," famous for breakfast and classic burgers.
• Bristol 45 Diner, Bristol - Offers hearty meals in a vintage 1950s setting with monthly events featuring classic cars and Elvis impersonations.
• Broadway Diner, Baraboo - Husband-and-wife-owned diner serving quick, delicious hash in a restored 1950s space.
• Gus’s Diner, Sun Prairie & Verona - Family-owned diner with all-day breakfast, large burgers, and a fresh salad bar.
• Hubbard Avenue Diner and Bakery, Middleton - Known for pies and classic comfort foods, with daily specials on chicken, fish, and pot roast.
• Club 23, Wisconsin Dells - Friendly atmosphere with hearty entrees including soup, salad, and potatoes, just off Highway 23.
• The Diner, Appleton - All-day diner with a wide menu from breakfast to homestyle dinners, plus an array of desserts.