Best Pizza in Illinois: Our 9 Favorites

Pequod’s Pizza, Chicago, IL

For a pan-sized pizza with a caramelized edge, head to Pequod’s Pizza in Chicago. Pequod’s has two locations, one in Chicago and the other in Morton Grove. This pizzeria originated in 1970 and has since developed a large following of loyal customers who appreciate Pequod’s signature pizza style. 

Bill’s Pizza & Pub, Mundelein, IL

If you’ve never had a double-decker pizza, look no further than Bill’s Pizza & Pub in Mundelein. Bill’s double decker pizza consists of two thin crust pizzas stacked on top of each other and a hand-rolled crust. Aside from the large pizza menu, guests can enjoy a scrumptious dessert like a chocolate chip cookie sundae or cheesecake. 

Coalfire, Chicago, IL

Coalfire is known for baking thin crust pizzas in clean-burning coal ovens. Pizza connoisseurs from everywhere appreciate the slightly charred, bubbly pizzas and signature toppings including vodka meatball and sopressata & broccolini. Guests can also build their own custom pizzas and choose from a wide variety of alcoholic beverages. 

Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria, Oak Park, IL

A traditional, Chicago-style deep dish pizza is best left to a professional such as Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria. This legendary pizzeria began in 1971 and has since developed a reputation for serving world-class Chicago-style deep pizzas. Lou Malnati’s also serves thin crust pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, appetizers, and other dishes. 

Connie’s Pizza, Chicago, IL

Connie’s Pizza is another legendary pizza tradition in Chicago. This family-owned business been serving up delicious deep dish pizzas and other Italian favorites since the early 1960s. Connie’s also won the Diners’ Choice award in 2015. 

Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria, Chicago, IL

Vito & Nick’s has arguably the best thin crust pizza in Chicago. Since 1946, this family business has been serving quality, in-house (never delivered) pizzas. The Vito & Nick’s House Special, which is a thin crust pizza with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, is a popular menu item. 

Fasano’s Pizza, Justice, IL

Fasano’s Pizza is also widely known for their freshly-made thin crust pizzas. Originating in 1972, this community favorite offers a wide variety of menu items including Italian beef sandwiches, lasagna, charbroiled ribs, and other specialties. There’s something for everyone at Fasano’s Pizza. 

Tre Amici Pizza, Palatine, IL

For excellent service and delicious pizza, Tre Amici Pizza is another fantastic choice. Popular menu items include the specialty pizzas, wings, and wraps. They also offer delicious sandwiches, ribs, chicken, pastas, and desserts. 

Harris Pizza, Rock Island, IL

Known for their superior hand-tossed pizzas, Harris Pizza has been family-owned for over 50 years. They have five locations and support many community efforts including the local animal shelter, food bank, and youth initiatives. They offer a great selection of specialty pizzas, wings with many dipping sauces, and delicious appetizers. 

Key Insights at a Glance

• Chicago is known for deep-dish pizza, but there are also delicious thin and hand-tossed pizza restaurants across Illinois.
• Many pizza restaurants in Illinois have been serving up pies for decades, perfecting their craft over the years.
• Pequod’s Pizza in Chicago is known for its pan-sized pizza with a caramelized edge.
• Bill’s Pizza & Pub in Mundelein offers a unique double-decker pizza and a variety of dessert options.
• Coalfire in Chicago bakes thin crust pizzas in clean-burning coal ovens with signature toppings.
• Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria in Oak Park is known for serving world-class Chicago-style deep dish pizzas.
• Connie’s Pizza in Chicago has been serving delicious deep dish pizzas and Italian favorites since the 1960s.
• Vito & Nick’s Pizzeria in Chicago is known for having arguably the best thin-crust pizza in the city.
• Fasano’s Pizza in Justice offers a wide variety of menu items including thin crust pizzas, Italian beef sandwiches, and more.
• Tre Amici Pizza in Palatine offers excellent service and a variety of menu items including specialty pizzas, wings, and wraps.
• Harris Pizza in Rock Island has been family-owned for over 50 years and offers superior hand-tossed pizzas and a variety of other menu items.